Beyond the Feed: The Women Quietly Reshaping New York - Karen Mitchell



New York has long been romanticised through the lens of television, where the lives of its women are often portrayed through designer wardrobes, extravagant apartments and glamorous social circles. From Sex and the City to The Real Housewives of New York City, popular culture has cultivated an image of the city in which success is measured by wealth, status and proximity to Manhattan's most exclusive addresses.
Yet beyond the glamour lies another New York, one built on ambition, resilience and the determination of women who have spent years establishing businesses, creating opportunities and challenging the status quo. These are the entrepreneurs, the hustlers and the quietly influential women whose stories rarely make it into television scripts, despite their contributions to the city's cultural and commercial landscape.
Throughout November, Vingt Sept Magazine will spotlight these women in a new editorial series exploring the realities of building a business, navigating adversity and defining success on their own terms. Through candid conversations about ambition, identity and legacy, we celebrate the real New Yorkers whose journeys deserve recognition.

We begin with Karen Mitchell, founder of True Indian Hair, who transformed a Brooklyn side hustle into an eight-figure beauty business, with a clientele that includes some of the world's most recognisable women. Beyond her commercial achievements, Mitchell has used her success to empower others through True Strength, her non-profit initiative supporting women experiencing hair loss following cancer treatment.
As the series unfolds throughout November, we will introduce more women whose stories offer a different perspective on what it means to succeed in New York. Because behind the city's carefully cultivated image are the women who aren't merely living the New York dream. They're building it.
Before True Indian Hair became a globally recognised luxury hair brand, you were building your career in a completely different industry while running a side business. Can you take us back to that chapter of your life, what you were doing before becoming an entrepreneur, and what made you realise there was an opportunity within the hair industry?
Before starting True Indian Hair, I worked in the fashion industry on the production end for a private label company. I oversaw the fabric colour approvals, making sure the client’s colour standard was reflected throughout the entire production of their order. My entire fashion career was spent with one company for 10 years, and it was during those latter years at the company, whilst on a trip to India, that I discovered Indian raw hair. I started selling the hair to my friends and family and then the surrounding community in Brooklyn.
You built True Indian Hair from Brooklyn, a neighbourhood with such a rich history of Black culture, entrepreneurship and creativity. What did Brooklyn mean to you during those early years, and how did the energy, community and diversity of the city influence the woman and entrepreneur you became?
I am a born Jamaican, but I was raised in Brooklyn since I was 12 years old, so I am a Brooklyn girl at my core. I grew up in Flatbush (Brooklyn), which has a vast Caribbean and Black American culture that moulded me.
My friends were Haitians, Panamanians, Trinidadians, and Americans. My mom was a hard-working single mother, and we didn’t have a lot. I believe being surrounded by such a melting pot made me a fighter. It made me strong, determined, and a hustler. I'm not sure I would be the woman I am today in business if I didn’t have that upbringing in Brooklyn. It was tough and diverse, but it was also beautiful.
You founded True Indian Hair in 2004, at a time when relatively few Black women were building beauty brands on this scale. What was the industry like when you entered it, and what challenges did you face in transforming a side hustle into a successful business?
I started the business as a side hustle whilst working in the fashion industry, so at the time, I didn't think I was building a brand. I was more focused on making some extra money on the side.
It was when I was laid off from my job in 2006 that I started taking my hair business more seriously because, by that point, it had become my sole source of income. I decided to open a store in 2007, and that was the moment I realised I had a business.
There were many obstacles, and I had no idea what I was doing. All I knew was that I had an amazing product on my hands, something new to my market in Brooklyn, and I believed that if I could get it out there, people would love it.
My biggest struggle was not having enough funding to stock the store. Even though the business was poised for growth, the pace was challenging because I didn't have enough stock to keep up with customer demand.
I also had no experience running a business before starting True Indian Hair, so I had to learn everything hands-on whilst building the brand. Customer service, marketing and managing my books were all things I had to learn along the way, and I made some mistakes in the process.

During the early years of True Indian Hair, you supplied sheitels to women within the Orthodox Jewish community before focusing on establishing the brand's reputation for luxury Indian hair extensions and wigs. How did those early experiences shape your understanding of craftsmanship, quality and the cultural and emotional significance of hair?
My journey didn't actually begin with creating sheitels. However, I did sell sheitels to a small group of Jewish clients during the early days of True Indian Hair. This wasn't common practice at the time, as sheitels were generally purchased through Jewish-owned stores within their communities.
For me, working with this niche clientele was based on trust in the quality of our products and in our understanding of the importance and value that the finished product held for each client.
Sheitels are made with European or Russian hair. They cannot be made with Indian hair, as Indian temple hair comes from a religious practice. Understanding and respecting the history of both was paramount to how I communicated with and marketed to different client bases.
However, it was challenging to grow the sheitel business under the umbrella of a company called True Indian Hair. We therefore decided to focus on building the True Indian Hair brand around Indian hair, which already accounted for the majority of our business.

Today, True Indian Hair has grown from a Brooklyn store into an eight-figure business with flagship locations, a global clientele and some of the most recognisable women in the world wearing your hair. When you reflect on that journey, what is the moment you realise, “I built this”?
I still find myself having moments when I think, "Wow, this is my company!"
One pivotal moment for me was about two years ago, when we had, I think, six celebrities wearing True Indian Hair at the Met Gala in New York, including Demi Moore, Rihanna and Naomi Campbell, to name a few.
I remember looking through the press coverage the day after the Met Gala and thinking, "Wow, that's my company, with six people on the red carpet wearing our hair!"
Then there are moments when a customer comes into our New York store and says, "I've been buying your hair since you were on Flatbush Avenue, advertising on the dollar vans."
That's a core memory from my early days, and knowing that clients from back then are still customers today always gives me goosebumps and an enormous sense of pride and accomplishment.
Hair has always been deeply connected to identity, confidence and self-expression, particularly within Black communities. You have helped transform conversations around extensions and wigs, moving them from something women often kept private into a form of luxury and empowerment. Why do you think that shift happened, and what role do you think brands like yours played in changing the narrative?
I've always believed that hair is an accessory. The same woman can wear a short bob on Monday, long waves on Friday and natural curls on holiday, and every one of those looks can authentically represent who she is.
After nearly 20 years in this industry, one of the biggest changes I've seen is that women no longer feel they have to whisper about wearing extensions or wigs. They celebrate them.
I'm proud that True Indian Hair has played a part in moving the conversation from secrecy to choice, luxury and empowerment. I think this shift happened because women became more comfortable embracing the fact that beauty can be enhanced and still feel authentic to who they are.
Your hair has appeared on red carpets, runways and on some of the world’s most influential women, including Rihanna, Beyoncé and Kim Kardashian. When someone with that level of cultural influence chooses your brand, what does that mean to you, and what does it represent about how far the industry has evolved?
For me, it's incredibly validating. When women at that level of influence, whose beauty and style choices can literally set global trends, choose to wear our hair, it shows that the quality of our products can stand alongside some of the biggest luxury beauty brands in the world.
But when I see our hair on those stages, I don't just see a celebrity wearing True Indian Hair. I see how far the industry has come, and I see a brand that started by serving everyday women becoming part of a much larger cultural and fashion story.
That, for me, is something I'm extremely proud of.
Behind the glamour is a business built on sourcing, craftsmanship and relationships. You have travelled to India and worked closely with suppliers to create the quality True Indian Hair is known for. What have those experiences taught you about building an ethical global business as a female founder?
You have to know where you're coming from to know where you're going. That statement also holds true for business and producing a quality product.
Travelling to India and meeting suppliers firsthand gave me a completely different perspective. It's one thing to order a product from across the world, but it's another to be on the ground, understand the culture, see the process, ask questions and build relationships.
As a female founder, I also learnt the importance of showing up and being present. I didn't want to simply accept what I was told. I wanted to understand the sourcing, quality, craftsmanship and business practices behind the product.
Those relationships have helped me establish standards and consistency for True Indian Hair. The experience also taught me that ethical business isn't a one-time conversation. It requires ongoing accountability and transparency.

Success has also allowed you to give back through True Strength, your nonprofit initiative providing hair and beauty makeovers for women experiencing hair loss due to cancer treatments. Why was it important for you to create a space where beauty could also become a form of healing?
True Strength was born out of a desire to give back to my community, and I felt the best way to do that was by providing a day of beauty for women who have experienced hair loss as a result of different forms of cancer, particularly breast cancer.
I wanted to make a difference in someone's life, put a smile on their face and give them a moment of joy. As a woman, I understand the importance of looking in the mirror and feeling good about yourself.
I also know that there are thousands of women who, when they lose their hair, feel as though they've lost their identity. I want to be able to give that back to as many women as I can.
This series celebrates women quietly reshaping New York. You built True Indian Hair from a Brooklyn side hustle into a global beauty company while creating opportunities for women to feel confident in themselves. What does legacy mean to you at this stage of your journey?
Legacy, to me, means True Indian Hair being recognised as more than just a hair extensions brand, but as a community of transformation.
A community that helped change the narrative by elevating extensions from simply being a beauty solution to becoming a luxury beauty choice, focused on quality, versatility and creating an experience that women could feel proud of.
It's about showing that extensions aren't just about covering something up. They can also be about self-expression, convenience, transformation and confidence.

When you think about the future of True Indian Hair, what do you hope the next chapter looks like, and what advice would you give women who are sitting on an idea but are waiting for the “right” moment to begin?
For me, the next chapter looks like expansion, both nationally and internationally. It looks like conversations, education and growing communities.
I want to continue evolving while staying true to what has sustained us for nearly 20 years: quality, authenticity and trust.
I see us expanding beyond simply selling hair and continuing to build a true lifestyle and beauty brand, creating products and experiences that grow with the women we serve.
Thank you to Karen Mitchell
Words by Jheanelle Feanny





Comments